Judy Greer turned down the role of Claire Dunphy in Modern Family due to concerns about typecasting and a desire to continue exploring different projects. She felt the role would limit her lifestyle and career opportunities.
Background and Initial Decision
Judy Greer was offered the role of Claire Dunphy in the popular sitcom “Modern Family” but turned it down. According to recent reflections by Greer, she didn’t feel ready for the commitment that came with playing a lead character in a long-running show.
Comparison to Julie Bowen’s Performance
When asked about her decision, some fans pointed out that Julie Bowen was perfect for the role of Claire Dunphy and that Judy Greer would have been wrong for the part. They believed that Greer’s acting style wouldn’t fit with the character’s personality.
Lifestyle Considerations
Greer mentioned in an interview that she wasn’t ready to settle down into a long-term role like Claire Dunphy at that time. She was enjoying her career and wanted to continue exploring different projects, including films and other TV shows. She stated that she likes traveling and meeting new people, which wouldn’t have been possible with the demanding schedule of “Modern Family”.
Julie Bowen’s Audition Experience
In a related interview, Julie Bowen reminisced about her audition for “Modern Family”. She confessed to feeling insecure during the process, stating that she thought she bombed because she couldn’t tell jokes and wasn’t funny. However, she went on to secure the role of Claire Dunphy.
Impact of Playing a Motherly Role
Some fans pointed out that playing a motherly role can lead to typecasting, making it difficult for actors to move away from such roles in the future. They noted that Judy Greer’s decision not to audition for “Modern Family” was likely influenced by this concern.
Conclusion
References
-
[2] Deadline.com – Judy Greer Explains Why She Turned Down Audition For ‘Modern Family’
-
[3] The Three Questions Podcast – Julie Bowen on Her Audition for Modern Family
Background on the Role
Claire Dunphy is a central character in the show, played by Julie Bowen. The character is a mother and wife, navigating family life with her husband Jay and their three children.
Judy Greer’s Decision
Judy Greer has explained that she turned down the role because she was not ready to play a mom on TV. At the time, kids were “not even on the table for me” in real life, and she didn’t want to be typecast as America’s mom.
Comparison with Movies
Greer noted that in movies, actors can have children and then forget about them after the film is over. However, in a TV show like Modern Family, the character’s role as a mother would be ongoing and constant.
Limitations of the Role
According to Greer, the role felt limiting compared to what she was doing already in her career. She liked traveling, working on different movies, and meeting new people, which she didn’t think would be possible with this role.
Quotes from Judy Greer
“I was like, ‘I don’t know if I want to be America’s mom yet.'”
“The role felt so limiting compared to what I was doing already. And in addition to just the perception of who you are as an actor. It’s lifestyle too.”
Related News
- eonline.com | Judy Greer Reveals Why She Turned Down Modern Family’s Claire Dunphy
- deadline.com | Judy Greer On Why She Turned Down Modern Family Audition
- livejournal.com | Judy Greer Explains Why She Turned Down Audition For Modern ...
